Film School: The Jeans Ad War of 2025

American Eagle feat. Sydney Sweeney (left) vs Gap feat. Katseye (right) American Eagle feat. Sydney Sweeney (left) vs Gap feat. Katseye (right)

Lessons in rage-bait versus virality as marketing strategies.

‘Better in Denim’, the jeans ad from Gap featuring Katseye…

… within days of its release, inspired viral response videos, and racked up nearly twice as many views on YouTube alone…

…. as the American Eagle jeans ads featuring Sydney Sweeney…

… which garnered infamy for its invocations of eugenics and white supremacy – arguably, by design:

@bee.better.company

A deep dive into The Downfall of Sydney Sweeney, and American Eagles calculated plan to manufacture relevance through outrage. #sydneysweeney #sydney #sweeney #marketing101 #downfall #beebetter #deepdive #videoessay #trending #mba #longvideo #euphoria #americaneagle #controversy #jeans #marketing #pr

♬ original sound – Bee better

Further Viewing

“You can’t be the CEO of the male gaze without becoming its product… you cannot rebrand your way out of a cultural critique that you refuse to acknowledge.” Afrodizjha looks at the American Eagle ad campaign controversy in the wider context of Sydney Sweeney’s career, and compares and contrasts with the ways other actresses before her have navigated their own sex symbol status. She argues that Sydney Sweeney has trapped herself in the “triple-threat hybird of old Hollywood” tropes she has sought to harness: blonde bombshell, femme fatale, and cool girl. “The question isn’t whether she’s empowered, it’s what she’s willing to sacrifice to stay chosen”: